The cost of employing young people could become a little less burdensome for UK retailers if recommendations in the new Milburn Review are adopted, with independent convenience stores among the businesses potentially in line to benefit.
Proposals to reduce the cost of employing younger workers, offer recruitment incentives to small businesses and expand apprenticeship support could create new opportunities for convenience retailers and wholesalers. But the measures are recommendations, not yet policy, and their impact will depend on what the Government chooses to implement.
Published on November 17, the report, From a Welfare State to a Working State: A new settlement for the next generation, sets out a 10-year plan to tackle the growing number of young people not in education, employment or training (NEET).
Led by former health secretary Alan Milburn, the review argues that the UK needs a fundamental shift in how it supports young people into work, with employers playing a much bigger role in creating entry-level jobs, apprenticeships and work experience.
For the grocery sector, the proposals are particularly relevant. Retail and hospitality together account for 37% of jobs held by 16 to 24-year-olds, making them central to the review's strategy.
The report acknowledges that higher employment costs have made recruitment more difficult, particularly in sectors such as retail and hospitality where margins are tight and younger people make up a significant part of the workforce.
So what exactly is being proposed, and what could it mean for convenience retailers and wholesalers?
1. Lower National Insurance costs for younger workers
One of the most significant proposals for convenience retailers is a planned reduction in employer National Insurance costs for workers aged 21 to 24.
The review recommends a five-year phased increase in the earnings threshold at which employers in retail and hospitality start paying employer National Insurance for this age group, from the current £5,000 to £10,000.
This would not be an immediate across-the-board cut. Milburn says the change should be introduced when fiscal conditions allow, with the threshold rising progressively over five years.
The report argues that this targeted approach would particularly benefit businesses employing younger workers on lower wages or fewer hours, including those working part-time and Saturday jobs.
It points to the impact of the 2025 National Insurance changes, when the employer rate increased from 13.8% to 15% and the secondary threshold fell from £9,100 to £5,000.
According to the review, these changes increased the annual cost of employing a full-time worker on the National Living Wage by around £800, before taking account of the Employment Allowance.
For independent retailers operating on tight margins, a higher threshold could make it more affordable to recruit younger staff or offer additional hours.
However, the proposed National Insurance relief is specifically aimed at retail and hospitality. Wholesale businesses are not explicitly included in this recommendation, although they could benefit from other proposed employer incentives.
2. Small businesses could receive up to £7,000 in hiring incentives
The review also proposes expanding the Youth Jobs Grant to encourage businesses to recruit young people who have been out of education, employment or training for at least six months.
Under the proposed scheme, an employer hiring an eligible 16 to 24-year-old would receive £3,000.
An additional £2,000 would be available when hiring someone facing greater barriers to employment, such as a care leaver or a disabled young person requiring significant additional support.
Crucially for independent convenience retailers and smaller wholesalers, the review proposes a further £2,000 premium for businesses employing fewer than 50 people.
This means an eligible small business could potentially receive up to £7,000 in combined support for hiring a young person facing additional barriers to employment.
The proposal would also widen eligibility beyond those claiming Universal Credit. Milburn estimates that 314,000 young people who are NEET are not in the benefits system, meaning they are currently missed by the existing scheme.
The review argues that support should follow the young person rather than their benefit status.
For smaller retailers, the additional payment could help offset some of the costs associated with recruitment, induction and training. It could also make taking a chance on someone with little or no previous work experience more financially viable.
The report proposes that the grant should reward retention as well as recruitment, with financial support structured to encourage employers to keep young people in work.
3. More support for apprenticeships
The review wants apprenticeships to become a more prominent route into employment for young people, particularly at Levels 2 and 3.
It recommends increasing the payment to employers creating an apprenticeship to £2,500 and extending the incentive to apprenticeship levy-paying employers.
This could be relevant to larger convenience operators, symbol groups, wholesalers and businesses with structured training programmes, as well as smaller operators looking to develop their workforce.
For the wholesale sector, where roles can span warehouse operations, logistics, sales, administration and management, apprenticeships could provide a route to developing skills and building a future talent pipeline.
The report also calls for more opportunities for young people to gain meaningful work experience, including workplace visits, job shadowing, shorter placements and longer-term placements.
4. A simpler route for employers to recruit young people
A recurring concern in the review is that employers currently face a fragmented system of recruitment support, apprenticeships, work experience and employment services.
It proposes a single point of access through a new Youth Opportunity Service (YOS), intended to make it easier for businesses to hire young people, provide work experience and support them once they are in employment.
The service would be established in every place in England, bringing together support that is currently spread across different programmes and institutions.
This could be particularly useful for smaller convenience retailers that do not have dedicated HR teams or the resources to navigate multiple government schemes.
The review recognises this challenge, stating: “Small businesses cannot” devote the same resources as larger employers to navigating complex recruitment and support systems.
Its ambition is to create a system that works for the smallest employer willing to give a young person a chance, with one route in, one named contact, simple rules and rapid help when problems arise.
5. Businesses encouraged to offer more first jobs and work experience
Beyond financial incentives, the review sets out a wider expectation for employers to help young people gain their first experience of working life.
It proposes an employer-led initiative called First Chance, built around three commitments: creating genuine first jobs, offering more youth apprenticeships and opening up meaningful work experience.
Around 90 employers had signed up to the initiative at the time the report was written, including Marks & Spencer, Octopus Energy and Lloyds Banking Group.
Large private employers joining the initiative are encouraged to consider making 10% of entry-level vacancies available to young people who are NEET or at significant risk of becoming so.
This is a proposed voluntary commitment, rather than a mandatory quota for businesses.
For convenience retailers, work experience could take different forms, from short placements and store visits to exposure to stock management, customer service, merchandising and retail operations.
The review also argues that employers should remove unnecessary experience requirements from entry-level roles and make recruitment processes more accessible to those trying to secure their first job.
For a sector that employs more than 456,000 people, the opportunity to create meaningful first jobs is considerable. According to the Association of Convenience Stores (ACS), 15% of convenience store employees are under 25, while 97% of people working in the sector are employed on permanent contracts.
6. What does it mean for the wholesale sector?
Although the review specifically identifies retail and hospitality as the starting point for proposed National Insurance relief, its wider hiring incentives and apprenticeship recommendations are not restricted to those sectors.
This means wholesalers could potentially benefit from the proposed Youth Jobs Grant, including the additional small-business premium where they meet the eligibility criteria.
The emphasis on apprenticeships and entry-level opportunities could also help wholesalers address recruitment and skills needs across warehouse operations, transport, logistics, customer service and administration.
Larger wholesale businesses could also participate in First Chance, helping to develop a pipeline of younger workers through apprenticeships, work placements and entry-level recruitment.
However, the review does not set out a separate package of measures specifically for wholesalers, and the proposed National Insurance threshold changes are not currently extended to the sector.
7. What happens next?
The Milburn Review is an independent set of recommendations, not legislation or an announcement that the proposed incentives are now available.
The Government will need to decide which measures to accept, how to fund them and when they can be introduced. In particular, the proposed National Insurance changes are dependent on the public finances and would be phased in over five years.
The review estimates that its wider employment incentive package would require around £1.1bn a year once fully scaled up and could help create an additional 170,000 job and apprenticeship opportunities.
The wider ambition is to reduce the proportion of young people not in education, employment or training to around 5% by 2036, compared with nearly one million young people currently outside education and work.
For convenience retailers and wholesalers, the significance of the review lies in its recognition that businesses cannot be expected to create more entry-level jobs without addressing the cost and practical barriers to hiring.
Commenting on the review report, Sarah Bradbury, IGD Chief Executive, comments: “IGD welcomes the Milburn review, in particular its focus on early intervention in connecting young people with opportunities in work, education and training.
"Reducing NEET numbers requires coordinated action and, as one of the UK's largest employers, the food and drink industry has a major role to play.
"Our cross-industry Feeding Britain’s Future movement aims to engage every UK secondary school by 2030, reduce future NEET numbers and inspire the next generation to pursue careers across the food system. Through our schools programme and the industry’s commitment to offering meaningful work experience for 11–16-year-olds, we can help young people build their work readiness and strengthen the pathways from education into future employment.
"Building on this momentum will require continued collaboration between businesses and government to help more young people access meaningful work experience.”
Helen Dickinson, Chief Executive at the British Retail Consortium, said: “Milburn’s landmark report is a call to action to address a moral as well as an economic crisis. The need for government action could not be clearer. He recognises that preparing young people for work is only half the answer.
"The other half is making sure there are jobs for them to go to and that requires reducing the cost of employment. Retail is uniquely placed with entry level jobs across the country, but retailers need the confidence and capacity to create those jobs and give young people their first step on the career ladder.”
“Milburn’s call to raise the NICs threshold for retail and hospitality is not only incredibly welcome, but essential. Retail is on the frontline of creating flexible and local entry-level jobs for young people. But between 2024 and 2026, 120,000 retail roles have been lost as retail’s employment costs rose by £6.5 billion, driven by higher National Insurance contributions and above-inflation increases to the National Living Wage. The government must get on and implement this critically important recommendation without delay.”


