Skip to content
Search
AI Powered
Latest Stories

Expert criticises WHO report on e-cigarettes for misrepresenting evidence

Expert criticises WHO report on e-cigarettes for misrepresenting evidence
iStock
Getty Images

A leading tobacco and alcohol researcher from University College London has criticised a new report by the World Health Organization (WHO), titled "Hooking the next generation: how the tobacco industry captures young customers", for making claims that do not accurately reflect current evidence on e-cigarettes.

Dr. Sarah Jackson, principal research fellow at UCL’s Tobacco and Alcohol Research Group, argued that the WHO report misrepresents the effectiveness of e-cigarettes as a smoking cessation tool.


“The report suggests there is ‘insufficient evidence’ that e-cigarettes are effective in helping people to stop smoking. In fact, a Cochrane review on this topic (recognised worldwide as the highest standard in evidence-based healthcare) has concluded that there is ‘high-certainty evidence’ from randomised controlled trials that e-cigarettes increase quit rates compared to nicotine replacement therapy,” Dr. Jackson stated.

She highlighted that the most recent Cochrane review included 88 trials with more than 27,000 participants and was supported by numerous observational studies.

Dr. Jackson also took issue with the report’s stance on the harm reduction potential of e-cigarettes. “The report suggests it is misleading to suggest that e-cigarettes offer a form of harm reduction compared to smoking cigarettes. Large evidence reviews, conducted independent of industry, consistently conclude that while vaping is not risk-free, it poses only a small fraction of the risks of smoking tobacco,” she emphasised.

Regarding the concern that e-cigarettes could serve as a gateway to smoking, particularly among non-smoking youth, Dr. Jackson acknowledged the widespread nature of this concern but noted the lack of causal evidence.

“Little evidence currently suggests this association is causal: just because vaping precedes smoking does not mean vaping causes smoking,” she explained. Dr. Jackson pointed out that if vaping caused smoking, declines in smoking rates would slow or reverse with increased vaping, but data indicates the opposite trend.

Prof Nick Hopkinson, professor of respiratory medicine at Imperial College London, however supported WHO's stance on the aggressive marketing tactics employed by the tobacco industry, emphasising that, although vaping is significantly less harmful than smoking and has proven effective in helping smokers quit, targeting youth through e-cigarette marketing is wholly unacceptable.

“Governments around the world need to take steps to introduce and enforce regulations to stop this," Prof Hopkinson, who also serves as the chair of Action on Smoking and Health (ASH), stated.

He criticised the UK government's previous failures to regulate e-cigarette marketing and implement an excise tax on these products. He also lamented the recent halt of the Tobacco and Vapes Bill, which aimed to raise the legal age of sale and mitigate youth vaping, due to the prime minister's decision to call a snap election.

“Whatever happens at the election, the next government will need to move swiftly to reintroduce these vital public health measures,” he said.

More for you

UK economy unexpectedly shrinks in January

A file photo of Buns and Buns restaurant in Covent Garden Market, London. Sectors like accommodation and food services are expected to be hit hard by higher living wage and employer national insurance contributions in April.

Photo: iStock

UK economy unexpectedly shrinks in January in blow to government

Britain's economy unexpectedly shrank in January, official data showed Friday, piling more pressure on the Labour government ahead of its Spring Statement on the economy.

Gross domestic product contracted 0.1 per cent in the month after GDP rose 0.4 per cent in December, the Office for National Statistics (ONS) said in a statement.

Keep ReadingShow less
Trump threatens tariffs on European wine and spirits in response to a European Union plan to impose tariffs on American whiskey

Barrels of bourbon are stacked in a barrel house at the Jim Beam Distillery on February 17, 2020 in Clermont, Kentucky.

Photo by Bryan Woolston/Getty Images

Trump threatens 200 per cent tariff on European alcohol

US president Donald Trump on Thursday threatened to slap a 200 per cent tariff on wine, cognac and other alcohol imports from Europe, opening a new front in a global trade war that has roiled financial markets and raised recession fears.

Stocks fell on the news, as investors worried that Trump would enact stiffer trade barriers around the world's largest consumer market. The S&P 500 finished the day more than 10 per cent below its record high reached last month, confirming the benchmark index for US stocks is in a correction.

Keep ReadingShow less
Gloucestershire Trading Standards underage test purchase operation

Products containing corrosive substances sold to minors by Gloucestershire shops

Photo: Gloucestershire County Council

Eight out of 10 Gloucestershire shops found selling corrosives to minors

An undercover operation by Gloucestershire Trading Standards has found most shops in the county selling products containing corrosive substances to underage buyers.

In total, 10 stores were visited and eight made sales to underage volunteers.

Keep ReadingShow less
Paul Bacon appointed as NewstrAid Operations Manager replacing Tom Rodger

Paul Bacon joins NewstrAid as Operations Manager

NewstrAid appoints Paul Bacon as new Operations Manager

Industry charity, NewstrAid, has announced the appointment of Paul Bacon to the role of Operations Manager.

Paul will join the NewstrAid team from 17 March and will take over from Tom Rodger, who is retiring at the end of the month.

Keep ReadingShow less
 ATM machine
Brits pull out nearly £80bn from LINK ATMs in 2024
Photo: iStock

Uneven transition: Where cash still clings on in Britain

The UK’s transition away from cash continues to accelerate, nearly five years after the COVID-19 pandemic, according to a report released today by LINK, the UK's cash access and ATM network.

While the trend towards a low-cash society is clear, the pace of this shift varies significantly across the country, indicating a complex and evolving payment landscape.

Keep ReadingShow less